Guide · 4 min read

Flat roof materials compared

A straight answer from a Staten Island roofer. Questions about your own roof? The inspection is free.

5.0 on Google from 83 reviews GAF Master Elite® roofer

By Loni, owner of ProLine Roofing. GAF Master Elite® contractor, licensed and insured.
Published · Updated

The short answer

For most flat roofs on Staten Island homes, the choice is TPO or EPDM. TPO is white with heat-welded seams and keeps rooms cooler; EPDM is black rubber, flexible and easy to repair. Both typically last 20 to 30 years. Modified bitumen is common on older roofs, and coatings extend sound ones. See flat roofing for how we decide.

Key takeaways

  • TPO and EPDM both typically last 20 to 30 years; modified bitumen 15 to 20; a coating 10 to 15 years per coat.
  • TPO's heat-welded seams suit roofs with many pipes and curbs; its white surface reflects summer heat.
  • EPDM rubber stays flexible in the cold and is simple to patch; its glued seams are where it needs watching.
  • A coating is not a new roof: it only works over a dry, sound, well-attached roof.
  • Drainage and flashing decide how long a flat roof lasts more than the membrane does.
Flat roof before and after: a worn, patched surface with water stains around the vents, then a new white TPO membrane run up the parapet walls
Flat roof before and after: a worn, patched surface with water stains around the vents, then a new white TPO membrane run up the parapet wallsPhoto: ProLine Roofing, Staten Island

What is a flat roof made of?

A “flat” roof is not quite flat: it is built with a slight slope so water runs to the drains. Whatever membrane you choose sits on top of the same layers, and most problems start where those layers meet a wall or a drain.

Cross-section of a flat roof From the bottom up: roof deck on joists, tapered insulation sloping to a drain, cover board and the waterproof membrane, which runs up the parapet wall under a metal coping. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
  1. Roof deck. Boards or plywood on the joists. Wet or rotted deck is replaced before anything goes on top.
  2. Tapered insulation. Boards cut with a built-in slope, so water runs to the drains instead of pooling.
  3. Cover board. A thin, hard board over the insulation that the membrane is attached to.
  4. Membrane. The waterproof layer: white TPO with heat-welded seams, or black EPDM rubber.
  5. Wall flashing. The membrane turned up the parapet wall. Most flat-roof leaks start at these edges.
  6. Coping. Metal cap over the top of the parapet that keeps water out of the wall.
  7. Drain. At the low point, clamped to the membrane. Blocked drains are the main cause of ponding.
  8. Parapet wall. The low wall around the roof edge on many attached houses and row houses.
Figure 1. Cross-section of a flat roof, layers stepped back so each one shows: deck, tapered insulation, cover board, membrane, wall flashing, coping and drain.Illustration: ProLine Roofing

TPO vs EPDM vs modified bitumen vs coatings

Feature TPO EPDM Modified bitumen Coating
What it is White single-ply membrane Black synthetic rubber Asphalt-based rolled roofing Liquid layer over an existing roof
Seams Heat-welded Glued or taped Torched or adhered Seamless
Typical life 20–30 years 20–30 years 15–20 years 10–15 years per coat
Summer heat Reflects it Absorbs it Absorbs it (unless capped white) Reflects it (white coatings)
Repairs Weld a patch Glue or tape a patch Torch or adhere a patch Recoat
Suits Many seams and penetrations, hot top floors Simple roofs, easy repairs Matching existing roofs Sound roofs that need more years

Which flat roof material should you choose?

  • Choose TPO if

    • The roof has many pipes, vents, curbs or a skylight to seal around
    • The room under it gets hot in summer
    • You want welded seams that act as one sheet
  • Choose EPDM if

    • The roof is a simple shape with few penetrations
    • Easy, low-cost patching matters to you
    • The roof sees foot traffic or movement
  • Choose a coating if

    • The existing roof is dry, sound and well attached
    • It needs more years, not a new system
    • You want a reflective surface without a tear-off
  • Choose a full replacement if

    • The roof is wet underneath or the deck is soft
    • There are already two layers
    • Seams and flashing have failed in several places

TPO: welded seams, white surface

TPO’s welded seams are its strength: overlapping sheets are fused with hot air into one continuous membrane, which matters on roofs with many seams, pipes and curbs. Its white surface reflects much of the summer sun, which keeps top-floor rooms cooler; the US EPA describes how reflective “cool roofs” lower roof temperatures. More on TPO roofing.

Flat roof before and after: a worn, patched surface with water stains around the vents, then a new white TPO membrane run up the parapet walls
Before and after: a worn, patched flat roof with stains around the vents, then a new white TPO membrane run up the parapet walls.Photo: ProLine Roofing, Staten Island

EPDM: flexible rubber, easy to patch

EPDM rubber has been used on flat roofs for decades. It stays flexible in cold weather, tolerates movement and is simple to patch. Its seams are glued or taped rather than welded, so seams and edges are where it needs watching. Being black, it absorbs heat in summer. More on EPDM rubber roofing.

Modified bitumen: the older standard

Many older flat roofs on the island are modified bitumen: asphalt-based rolls, often with a granule surface, torched or adhered in overlapping layers. It is tough but ages in the sun, cracks at the seams and is usually replaced with TPO or EPDM when it wears out.

Coatings: more years for a sound roof

A coating is not a new roof. It seals and protects a sound existing roof, adds years and, if white, reflects heat. It is the right choice only when the roof underneath is dry and well attached; over a wet roof it traps the water in. More on flat roof coatings.

Red protective coating half applied to a flat rooftop deck with a railing, the bucket beside it
A protective coating going onto a sound flat roof deck. Coatings extend a dry, well-attached roof; they do not fix a wet one.Photo: ProLine Roofing, Staten Island

What matters more than the material?

Drainage. Every flat-roof material wears out fast under standing water. A common rule of thumb: water still on the roof two days after the rain stops is ponding. Before choosing a membrane, make sure the roof drains: drains at the low points, clear and big enough, and slope built in with tapered insulation where needed.

Flashing. The second thing that decides how long any flat roof lasts is the flashing at parapet walls, drains, hatches and pipes. Most flat-roof leaks start at an edge, not in the middle of the membrane.

How long does a flat roof replacement take?

Most flat roof replacements take 3 to 5 days, depending on the size, the number of old layers to remove, the drainage work and access. Flat roofs are priced by the job after a free inspection; see flat roofing for how we inspect and what the written estimate covers.

Sources and further reading

Prices are our published Staten Island ranges. Everything else comes from our own inspections and installs unless a source is listed.

FAQ

Related questions

Which flat roof material should I choose?

There is no single right answer. TPO suits roofs with many seams and hot top floors; EPDM suits roofs where easy repair matters; coatings suit sound roofs that need more years. Drainage and installation matter more than the material.

How long do flat roofs last?

TPO and EPDM typically last 20 to 30 years, modified bitumen 15 to 20, and a coating 10 to 15 years per coat.

Can I put a new flat roof over the old one?

Sometimes, over a single dry, sound layer with a cover board. If the old roof is wet or there are already two layers, it has to come off.

Is water standing on my flat roof a problem?

Some water for a day after rain is normal. Water still there two days after the rain stops is ponding, and it shortens the life of any membrane. Drains, slope and tapered insulation fix it.

How much does a flat roof cost?

Flat roofs are priced by the job after a free inspection, because size, drainage, insulation, parapets and access vary so much from one roof to the next.

Free estimate

Get a straight answer about your roof

  1. We call you back
    Usually the same day, to book a time that suits you.
  2. We come to you
    The owner inspects at your home, photographs what he finds and shows you.
  3. You get a written price
    Free, with no obligation. The exact figure, on paper.

Rather talk? Call (347) 323-9128. Open 24/7 for leaks.

Tell us about your roof

Four quick answers. We call you back, usually the same day.

Enter your name.
Enter a 10-digit phone number.
Enter a 5-digit ZIP code.

We use your details only to call you about this estimate. Privacy policy

Free estimate

Three quick steps

What do you need?
Where is the roof?

We cover every Staten Island ZIP.

Where do we call you back?
Enter your name.
Enter a 10-digit phone number.

Free, no obligation. We call you back, usually the same day. Privacy

Rather talk? (347) 323-9128