Five things that move your price
- Size. More squares, more material and more labor. A large two-story colonial and a small cape sit at opposite ends of the range.
- Pitch. Steep roofs are slower and need more safety equipment. Above about 8 in 12, expect the price to rise.
- Layers to remove. Each extra layer of old shingles adds tear-off time and disposal weight.
- Decking. Rotted roof boards under the old shingles have to be replaced. Nobody can know exactly how many until the old roof is off, so a good estimate states how decking is priced.
- Materials and details. The shingle line, skylights, chimneys, valleys and dormers all add work and flashing.
What a fair estimate includes
A fair roofing estimate says what is being done, with what, and for how much: tear-off and disposal, the number of layers, decking repairs and how they are priced, underlayment, ice and water barrier, drip edge, flashing, the shingle product and color, ventilation, clean-up, the timeline, and the warranty on materials and workmanship. Our guide on how to read a roofing estimate goes through it line by line.
Red flags in a quote
- A price given over the phone without anyone looking at the roof.
- No mention of tear-off, underlayment or flashing.
- A large cash deposit before any materials are delivered.
- No licence number on the estimate. In New York City, home improvement contractors must be licensed; ours is NYC HIC #2120969-DCWP.
- Pressure to sign the same day.
Repair first, if a repair will do
Not every roof needs replacing. If the damage is local and the rest of the roof is sound, a roof repair in the $250 to $1,000+ range is the right answer, and we will tell you so. When the roof is worn across the board, see roof replacement, and for flat roofs, flat roofing.
The Staten Island Roof Cost Index
We are building a record of real job prices on Staten Island, by roof type, size and part of the island, from our own invoices. We will publish it here with the method and sample sizes, and update it every quarter.