By Loni, owner of ProLine Roofing. GAF Master Elite® contractor, licensed and insured.
Published · Updated
The short answer
A roofing estimate should say what is done, with what, and for how much: tear-off and layers, decking and how it is priced, underlayment and ice barrier, drip edge, flashing, the shingle product, ventilation, clean-up, timeline, warranty and licence number. If a line is missing, ask. Our Staten Island roof cost guide shows the published price ranges.
Key takeaways
- Compare quotes line by line, not by the total: a cheaper quote usually leaves something out.
- The lines most often missing are tear-off, decking price per sheet, ice and water barrier, new flashing and ventilation.
- A fair estimate names the shingle by brand, product line and color, and states both warranties in writing.
- In New York City, home improvement contractors must be licensed. The licence number belongs on the estimate.
- A price given over the phone, with no one looking at the roof, is not an estimate.
What should a roofing estimate include?
A complete estimate answers three questions in writing: what will be done, with which materials, and for how much. Here is a sample of what a complete roof replacement proposal looks like, line by line, with what to check on each line.
Roof replacement proposal Sample
- HeaderContractor name, address, phone · NYC licence no. ______ · Date · Your name and address A licence number you can look up. In NYC, home improvement contractors must be licensed.
- Roof size24 squares (2,400 sq ft of roof surface), pitch 7/12 Squares, not just "the roof". Pitch affects labor.
- Tear-offRemove 2 layers of shingles to the deck; haul away How many layers come off. "Install over existing" is a different job.
- DeckingReplace rotted sheathing at $___ per sheet, est. 6 sheets A price per sheet, so the total cannot jump once the roof is open.
- Ice & water barrierEaves (min. 3 ft), all valleys, around chimney and skylight Where it goes, not just "as needed".
- UnderlaymentSynthetic underlayment over the full deck Full coverage under the shingles.
- Drip edgeNew metal drip edge, eaves and rakes New, on every edge.
- FlashingNew step and counter-flashing at chimney; new pipe boots New, not "reuse existing".
- ShinglesGAF Timberline HDZ®, color: Charcoal, with matching hip and ridge Brand, product line and color by name.
- VentilationRidge vent; clear soffit intake Both intake and exhaust.
- Clean-upDaily clean-up, magnetic nail sweep, dumpster Nails swept from the yard and driveway.
- Timeline & warranty2 days · Manufacturer warranty: ____ · Workmanship: ____ years, in writing Both warranties, each in writing.
- Price & termsTotal $______ · Deposit ___% on material delivery · Balance on completion One total for the scope above, and when each payment is due.
The lines every estimate should have
- Your name, address and the date. And the contractor’s name, address, phone and licence number. In New York City, home improvement contractors must be licensed.
- Roof size. Usually in squares: one square is 100 square feet of roof surface.
- Tear-off. Whether the old roof comes off, and how many layers. “Install over existing” is a different, cheaper and usually worse job.
- Decking. How rotted roof boards found after tear-off are handled and priced: per sheet, per board, or included up to a stated amount.
- Underlayment and ice and water barrier. What goes under the shingles, and where the barrier goes (eaves, valleys, around chimneys and skylights).
- Drip edge. New metal edge along the eaves and rakes.
- Flashing. New flashing at chimneys, walls and vents, not “reuse existing” unless there is a good reason.
- Shingles. The brand, product line and color, not just “architectural shingles”.
- Ventilation. Ridge vents, intake vents, or what is being kept.
- Clean-up and disposal. Including nails from the yard.
- Timeline. How many days the job takes.
- Warranty. On the materials, by product, and on the workmanship, in writing.
- Price and payment terms. The total and when payments are due.
The words on an estimate, explained
Most of the terms on a roofing estimate are parts of the roof. This cutaway shows where each one is.
- Ridge vent. Lets hot, damp attic air out along the peak.
- Shingles. The weather surface. Their granules shield the asphalt from the sun.
- Underlayment. A water-resistant sheet over the whole deck: the second line of defense.
- Ice and water barrier. Self-adhesive membrane at the eaves, valleys and around chimneys. Seals around nails against ice dams.
- Roof deck (sheathing). The plywood or boards everything is nailed to. Rotted sections are replaced at tear-off.
- Drip edge. Metal along the edge that steers water into the gutter instead of behind it.
- Gutter. Carries water to the downspouts. When it clogs, water backs up under the roof edge.
- Soffit vent. Air intake under the eaves. With the ridge vent it keeps the attic air moving.
- Rafters. The framing that carries the roof. A sagging roof line points here.
- Chimney flashing. Step and counter-flashing that seals the joint between chimney and roof.
- Square: 100 square feet of roof.
- Pitch: steepness, written as rise over 12 inches of run, for example 6 in 12. Steeper roofs take longer and cost more.
- Tear-off: removing the old roof down to the deck.
- Decking or sheathing: the boards or plywood the roof is nailed to.
- Underlayment: the water-resistant layer under the shingles.
- Ice and water barrier: a self-adhesive membrane at the eaves and valleys that seals around nails.
- Drip edge: metal at the roof’s edge that sends water into the gutter.
- Flashing: metal that seals the joints at chimneys, walls, vents and skylights.
- Rakes and eaves: the sloped edges at the gable ends, and the bottom edges where the gutters are.
- Valley: where two roof slopes meet in a V and water collects.
More words, from cricket to kick-out flashing, are in our roofing glossary.
How do you compare two roofing quotes?
Put them side by side and go line by line. If one is much cheaper, look for what it leaves out. Here is a typical pair:
| Line | Quote A | Quote B | What it means |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tear-off | 2 layers to the deck | Not mentioned | B may be a roof-over |
| Decking | Price per sheet stated | “As needed” | B’s total can grow once the roof is open |
| Ice and water barrier | Eaves, valleys, chimney | Not mentioned | B may skip it |
| Flashing | New step and counter-flashing | “Reuse existing” | Old flashing is the most common leak point |
| Shingles | Brand, line and color named | “Architectural shingles” | You cannot check what B installs |
| Warranty | Material and workmanship, in writing | “Full warranty” | Ask B what, how long and who honors it |
The cheaper quote often grows once the old roof is off. A detailed estimate with photos of your roof costs nothing to get, and it is your strongest protection.
Red flags in a roofing quote
- A price over the phone with no one looking at the roof.
- No tear-off, underlayment or flashing on the page.
- No licence number.
- “Decking as needed” with no price per sheet.
- Pressure to sign today, or a large cash deposit up front.
- A storm-chaser who knocks on your door after bad weather, with an out-of-town address.
Questions to ask before you sign
- Is the old roof coming off to the deck, and how many layers are there?
- What does a sheet of replacement decking cost, and how many are included?
- Which shingle, by brand, line and color? Can I see a sample?
- Is the flashing new everywhere, including the chimney?
- Where does the ice and water barrier go?
- Who will be on the roof, and who do I call during the job?
- What does each warranty cover, for how long, and is it registered with the manufacturer?
- When is each payment due?
Our own estimates answer every one of these on paper, with photos of your roof. See the roof cost page for our published price ranges.
Sources and further reading
- NYC Department of Consumer and Worker Protection, Home Improvement Contractor license
- NYC Open Data, Issued Licenses (look up a contractor)
Prices are our published Staten Island ranges. Everything else comes from our own inspections and installs unless a source is listed.