Guide · 4 min read

Signs you need a new roof

A straight answer from a Staten Island roofer. Questions about your own roof? The inspection is free.

5.0 on Google from 83 reviews GAF Master Elite® roofer

By Loni, owner of ProLine Roofing. GAF Master Elite® contractor, licensed and insured.
Published · Updated

The short answer

The clearest signs are shingles curling, cracking or bald across the roof, granules piling up in the gutters, leaks returning in new places, soft or sagging decking and daylight through the roof boards. One sign in one spot usually means a repair; several across the roof usually mean roof replacement. An inspection with photos tells you which.

Key takeaways

  • Signs across the whole roof point to age and replacement; a sign in one spot usually points to a repair.
  • Granules in the gutters and curling on the sunny slope are usually the first signs, years before a leak.
  • Daylight through the roof boards, a sagging roof line or soft decking need attention soon, whatever the roof's age.
  • You can check most signs safely from the ground, the gutters, the attic and the top-floor ceilings. Do not walk on the roof.
Drone view of the ProLine crew in red shirts stripping old shingles to the boards on a Staten Island house, tarps covering the walls and yard below
Drone view of the ProLine crew in red shirts stripping old shingles to the boards on a Staten Island house, tarps covering the walls and yard belowPhoto: ProLine Roofing, Staten Island

What are the signs you need a new roof?

A roof that needs replacing shows it in four places: on the shingles, in the gutters, in the attic and on the top-floor ceilings. Here are the ten signs we look for on every inspection, what each one looks like and what it usually means.

  • Curling or cupping shingles

    Edges turning up, or the middle dishing down. Shows on the sunny slope first and means the shingles are drying out.

    Across the roof: replacement

  • Cracked shingles

    Splits across the tabs, often after a cold winter. A few after a storm are a repair; cracks everywhere are age.

    Across the roof: replacement

  • Bald patches

    Smooth, dark areas where the granules have washed off and the asphalt is exposed to the sun.

    Across the roof: replacement

  • Granules in the gutters

    Coarse grit piling up in the gutters and at the downspouts, year after year. A little after a new roof is normal.

    Across the roof: replacement

  • Missing shingles

    Tabs blown off in a moderate wind. One area is a repair; tabs going in every storm means the seals have aged out.

    One spot: usually a repair

  • Moss and dark streaks

    Streaks are algae and mostly cosmetic. Moss holds water against the shingles and lifts them.

    Get it checked soon

  • A sagging roof line

    A dip in the ridge or between rafters. Points to wet, rotted decking or a framing problem.

    Get it checked soon

  • Daylight in the attic

    Light through the roof boards, at nails or along the edges. If light gets in, so does water.

    Get it checked soon

  • Stains on top-floor ceilings

    Brown rings or peeling paint. Usually one leak with one cause, found by checking the attic above.

    Get it checked soon

  • Cracked flashing or caulk

    Gaps or tar patches where the roof meets a chimney, wall or skylight. The most common leak point, and a repair.

    One spot: usually a repair

The difference between a repair and a replacement is almost always how widespread the sign is. A few cracked shingles after a storm are a repair. Cracked shingles on every slope mean the roof has reached the end of its life.

Where should you look?

You do not need to climb a ladder to check most of these. Start outside with binoculars, then the gutters, then the attic with a flashlight on a sunny day, and finish with the ceilings of the top floor.

Where to look for roof problems A house with numbered spots: the roof line, the shingles, the chimney flashing, vent pipes, the gutters and downspouts, and the attic and top-floor ceilings. 1 2 3 4 5 6
  1. The roof line. Sight along the ridge from across the street. It should be straight; a dip means trouble underneath.
  2. The shingle field. Curling, cracking, bald or missing shingles. Check the sunny south and west slopes first.
  3. Chimney and walls. Flashing should be metal, tight and rust-free, not smeared with tar.
  4. Vents and pipe boots. Cracked rubber boots around plumbing vents are a common, cheap-to-fix leak.
  5. Gutters and downspouts. Granules, sagging sections, and water spilling over the edge in rain.
  6. Attic and ceilings. Daylight, stains and soft boards in the attic; brown rings on top-floor ceilings.
Figure 1. Where to look for the signs of a worn roof, from the ground, the gutters, the attic and inside.Illustration: ProLine Roofing

Signs you can see from the ground

  • Curling and cupping. Shingle edges turning up, or the middle of each shingle dishing down. Common on the sunny side first.
  • Cracking. Splits across shingles, especially after cold winters.
  • Bald patches. Dark, smooth areas where the protective granules have washed away and the asphalt underneath is exposed to the sun.
  • Missing shingles after moderate wind, a sign the seals between shingles have aged out.
  • A sagging roofline. A dip in the ridge or between rafters points to a deck or structural problem.
  • Moss and dark streaks on shaded slopes. Streaks are algae and mostly cosmetic; moss holds moisture against the shingles.

What do granules in the gutters mean?

Shingle granules look like coarse sand or grit. A handful after a new roof is normal: loose granules from manufacturing wash off in the first rains. Heaps of them in the gutters and at the bottom of the downspouts year after year mean the shingles are losing their protective layer, and the asphalt underneath will dry and crack faster.

What to look for in the attic

Take a flashlight on a sunny day and look at the underside of the roof:

  • Daylight through the boards, especially around nails or at the edges.
  • Water stains, dark rings or damp patches on the rafters and decking.
  • Soft or delaminating plywood. Press gently with a screwdriver handle: sound wood is firm.
  • Damp insulation, mold or a musty smell. These often point to ventilation as much as to the roof.
  • Frost on the nails in winter: warm, wet air from the house condensing in a poorly ventilated attic.

Signs inside the house

Ceiling stains and peeling paint on top-floor ceilings, and a top floor that is much hotter than the rest of the house in summer, can all point to the roof. A stain is rarely right under the hole: water runs along rafters and boards first. That is why we always check the attic above a stain.

Drone view of the same Staten Island house with white GAF synthetic underlayment over the whole roof and the crew starting the shingles
The same house after tear-off: the old roof is down to the deck, and new synthetic underlayment covers it before the shingles go on.Photo: ProLine Roofing, Staten Island

Check your own roof

Tick what you can see. The answer weighs how many signs there are and whether they point to age across the roof or to one spot.

Roof self-check

Tick everything you can see without climbing on the roof.

From the ground
In the gutters
In the attic
Inside the house

0 signs ticked

Nothing ticked yet. A roof with no signs needs a look every few years and after big storms.

Book a free inspection

One sign or many?

A single sign in a single spot, such as one stain under a chimney or a few shingles off after a storm, usually means a repair; see roof repair. Several signs across the roof, on an older roof, usually mean replacement. Our guide on whether to repair or replace goes through the decision with a chart and a calculator, and our guide to how long a roof lasts shows where your roof is likely to be in its life.

If you are not sure, a free inspection with photos settles it. We photograph the whole roof, not just the problem, and tell you plainly which side of the line it is on.

Sources and further reading

Prices are our published Staten Island ranges. Everything else comes from our own inspections and installs unless a source is listed.

FAQ

Related questions

What are the first signs a roof needs replacing?

Granules in the gutters and shingles starting to curl or crack on the sunny side are usually the first visible signs, before any leak.

Does one leak mean I need a new roof?

No. A single leak usually has a single cause, such as flashing or a vent boot, and can be repaired. Repeated leaks in different places on a worn roof are a different story.

Can I check my roof myself?

From the ground with binoculars, and from the attic with a flashlight, yes. Do not walk on the roof; it is dangerous and can damage worn shingles.

Are dark streaks on my roof a sign it needs replacing?

Not on their own. Dark streaks are usually algae and mostly cosmetic. Moss is different: it holds water and lifts shingles, so it should be dealt with.

How often should a roof be inspected?

Every few years, after any serious storm, and before you buy or sell a house. A roof over 15 years old is worth a look every year or two.

Free estimate

Get a straight answer about your roof

  1. We call you back
    Usually the same day, to book a time that suits you.
  2. We come to you
    The owner inspects at your home, photographs what he finds and shows you.
  3. You get a written price
    Free, with no obligation. The exact figure, on paper.

Rather talk? Call (347) 323-9128. Open 24/7 for leaks.

Tell us about your roof

Four quick answers. We call you back, usually the same day.

Enter your name.
Enter a 10-digit phone number.
Enter a 5-digit ZIP code.

We use your details only to call you about this estimate. Privacy policy

Free estimate

Three quick steps

What do you need?
Where is the roof?

We cover every Staten Island ZIP.

Where do we call you back?
Enter your name.
Enter a 10-digit phone number.

Free, no obligation. We call you back, usually the same day. Privacy

Rather talk? (347) 323-9128