8 min readBy the ProLine Roofing team, Staten IslandUpdated October 2026
The short answer

A full asphalt shingle roof replacement on Staten Island costs about $5,000 to $15,000+ and takes one to two days once work starts. Metal and tile cost more up front and last longer. Your roof’s size, pitch, layers and decking set the price, and a written estimate fixes it before work begins.

Step 1: Decide whether you need a replacement

Many roofs need a repair, not a new roof. Start with the question that fits your situation.

Step 2: Know what it costs

Most Staten Island homeowners pay in this range for a standard asphalt shingle roof. Large roofs, steep pitches and premium materials push past the top.

Full asphalt shingle replacement$5,000 – $15,000+Tear-off, underlayment, flashing, shingles, ventilation, cleanup and disposal. Small roofs land near the low end. Complex roofs land higher.
1

Size and pitchMore squares and steeper slopes mean more material, more labor and more safety gear.

2

Layers to removeTearing off two layers of old roofing takes longer than one.

3

Decking repairsRotted wood shows up at tear-off. Insist on a per-sheet price in writing before work starts.

4

Chimneys, skylights and dormersEach one adds flashing work.

5

Permit and disposalDumpster, haul-away and permit costs belong in the quote, not on a surprise invoice.

The full breakdown, with a cost-per-year comparison and red flags to watch for, is in our roofing costs guide.

Step 3: Pick a material

Asphalt shingles fit most homes. Longer-lasting materials cost more now and less per year of life. Tap a card for the full page.

Step 4: What the process looks like

Here is how a professional replacement runs from first call to final walkthrough.

  1. 1
    Inspection and written estimateWe measure the roof, check the decking and attic ventilation, and write up every line.
  2. 2
    Material and colorYou choose a material and shade. We show you samples.
  3. 3
    Permit and schedulingWe confirm what permit your job needs, who files it and the start date.
  4. 4
    Tear-off and deck checkThe crew strips the old roof and inspects the wood. Any decking repair follows the per-sheet price you approved.
  5. 5
    InstallationUnderlayment, drip edge, flashing, shingles and ventilation go on in order.
  6. 6
    Cleanup and walkthroughWe sweep the lawn and driveway with a magnet for nails, haul away debris and walk the job with you before final payment.
Day 1Strip and prepareTear-off, decking check and repairs, underlayment and flashing.
Day 2Shingle and finishShingles, ridge and vents, cleanup and the walkthrough. Large or complex roofs and rain add days.

Ready to see the number for your roof? We measure, check the decking and write down every line. The estimate is free.

Get my free estimate

Step 5: Permits and paperwork

In New York City, roof work often needs a Department of Buildings permit, and the rules depend on the scope of your job. A common rule of thumb is that replacing more than about a quarter of the roof needs one, and structural changes such as new dormers need filed plans. Rules change, so we confirm what applies and who files it before work starts.

Red flag: a roofer who offers to skip the permit to save you money. Unpermitted work can cause trouble with insurance claims and when you sell the house.

Step 6: Choose the right roofer

The lowest bid and the best bid are often two different bids. Check these before you sign.

Verify

  • A current NYC home improvement contractor license number (ours is HIC #2120969-DCWP)
  • Proof of insurance you can see
  • An itemized written estimate
  • Shingle brand and line named
  • Written workmanship warranty terms
  • Recent reviews from nearby homes

Walk away from

  • A single-number quote with no detail
  • Pressure to sign today
  • No decking price before tear-off
  • Large cash payment up front
  • "We can skip the permit"
  • No license number on paper

Not sure what to ask? Use the ten-line checklist in our roofing costs guide.

Timing tip: Late spring and early fall give you the best weather and the fewest delays. Our season-by-season guide has the details. A leak cannot wait, so call us any time.

Questions we hear

How much does a roof replacement cost on Staten Island?

About $5,000 to $15,000+ for a standard asphalt shingle roof. Metal, tile and cedar cost more. Your written estimate gives the exact number.

How long does it take?

Most asphalt shingle roofs take one to two days once work starts. Large or complex roofs and bad weather add time.

Do I need to be home?

No, but we walk the job with you before final payment. Plan to move cars away from the house and expect noise.

Will you replace the decking?

We replace the sections that are rotted or damaged. You approve the per-sheet price before work begins.

Can I live in the house during the work?

Yes. Expect noise and vibration, and move fragile items off attic-level walls and shelves.

Does insurance cover a replacement?

It depends on your policy. Sudden storm damage may be covered, and age-related wear often is not. Call your insurer first. We provide photos and a written report you can send them.

Get your roof replacement price in writing

Free inspection, itemized estimate, no pressure. We tell you whether you need a replacement or a repair.

ProLine Roofing481 Mill Rd, Staten Island, NY 10306 · Licensed and insured, HIC #2120969-DCWP · Open 24/7 for leaks