Asphalt Shingle Roofing in Staten Island: Costs, Pros & Cons, and More (2024)

Let’s face it, the prospect of replacing your roof is probably not your idea of fun. There’s a lot to think about, and with Staten Island’s storms, you need a roof you can count on. Asphalt shingle roofs are a popular choice for a reason, so let’s break down everything you need to know: the good, the not-so-good, and whether they’re the right solution for your Staten Island home.

Asphalt Shingles Basics

A GAF asphalt shingle composition. Credits:

All right, let’s get down to the basics of asphalt shingles. Think of them as a layered sandwich:

  • The base layer: This is fiberglass. It gives the shingle strength and a little flexibility to handle the stress of weather changes.
  • The waterproofing: That’s the asphalt. This sticky stuff is what keeps the rain from pouring into your attic.
  • The Protective Coating: These colorful little granules aren’t just for looks! They protect the asphalt from the sun’s harsh UV rays and add some fire resistance.

Types of asphalt shingles

3-Tab Shingles: These are the simplest and most budget-friendly option. Think of them as a uniform grid, a classic but slightly flat look.

Architectural shingles: Sometimes called dimensional shingles. They have extra layers that give your roof more depth and visual interest. They also tend to be a bit thicker and more durable than 3-ply.

The benefits of asphalt shingles: Advantages for Staten Island Homeowners

Wallet-friendly: When it comes to roofing materials, asphalt shingles are generally the most affordable option upfront.

Plenty of Choices: You won’t be limited to just a few colors. Asphalt shingles come in a wide variety of shades and styles to match your home.

Relatively quick installation: Compared to some more complex roofing materials, asphalt shingles usually mean a quicker installation process, usually within 1 to 2 days, which can potentially save some money on labor costs.

Factors to Consider

Asphalt shingles have some advantages, but they’re not a one-size-fits-all solution.  Here’s what you need to think about before you make that call:

The Staten Island storms

We get our fair share of rain, high winds, maybe even some hail. Asphalt shingles do a good job, but extreme weather can take a toll. If you’re right on the coast, you may want to consider super wind-resistant options or even something like metal roofing.

Is your roof steep?

Asphalt shingles work on a variety of roof slopes, but super-steep ones may be better suited for other materials. A good roofing contractor can advise you on what works best with your home’s design.

The lifespan question: Asphalt roofs don’t last forever. Generally, you’re looking at 15-30 years, depending on the quality of the shingles, how well they’re installed, and our Staten Island weather. Some other materials like metal or tile can last much longer.

Appearance matters: Does your home have a certain style? Asphalt shingles are versatile, but if you’ve got a historic Victorian, you may want to explore materials that complement that aesthetic even better.

Maintenance and Repairs

Even the best roof needs a little attention. Here’s what you need to know about asphalt shingles:

What to look for:

  • Missing granules: If you see bare, dark spots, it’s a sign of aging and wear.
  • Cracked or curled shingles: These are susceptible to wind and water damage.
  • Algae and moss growth: Especially in shaded areas, these can shorten the life of your roof.

DIY or Pro?

Small repairs, such as replacing a missing shingle or two, are often manageable for the DIY homeowner if you have the right tools. But for more extensive problems, or if you don’t like heights, calling a roofer is the safest bet.

Don’t skip inspections

The best way to catch problems early is with regular inspections.  You can do a quick visual check from the ground, and getting a professional up on the roof annually (or after major storms) is smart preventive maintenance.

Pro tip: It’s much easier and cheaper to fix small problems than it is to deal with major leaks caused by neglected repairs!

Is Asphalt the Answer for You?

Let’s get this straight!  Asphalt shingle roofing definitely has its advantages, especially for budget-conscious Staten Island homeowners. However, it’s important to consider the potential drawbacks as well.

A quick recap

Pros: Affordable, wide variety of styles, relatively easy to install.

Cons: Shorter lifespan than some alternatives, susceptible to extreme weather, may not suit all architectural styles.

The Cost vs. Durability Question

Asphalt shingles win hands down on initial cost. Keep in mind, however, that you may need to replace them sooner than materials like metal or tile, which often have much longer life spans. It’s a matter of deciding whether that initial affordability outweighs the potential for a longer-lasting (but more expensive) roof down the road.

Want a quick comparison?

Asphalt shingles are a great middle ground.  They provide a solid option for many homes.  But if extreme weather resistance is your top priority, metal roofing may be a better choice.  If you have an architecturally unique home and want a roof that lasts 50+ years, then tile starts to make sense.

Average Costs of Asphalt Shingle Roofing in Staten Island

Now let’s talk dollars and cents, because that’s a big factor for most homeowners. Here’s a breakdown of what goes into the cost of an asphalt shingle roof on Staten Island:

  • Size of your roof: A larger roof requires more materials and labor, so it naturally costs more.
  • Shingle Quality: 3-Tab shingles are cheaper up front, architectural shingles cost more but tend to last longer.
  • Complexity: Rooflines with many angles, valleys, or dormers make installation more difficult, which drives up the price.
  • Roof accessibility: Difficult access can increase labor time and the need for specialized equipment.
  • Local labor costs: Roofing rates in our area can vary from company to company.
  • Tear-Off vs. Layover: Removing the old shingles before installing the new roof will increase costs.

Price Range

A new asphalt shingle roof typically costs between $5,994 and $18,791 or more.  This translates to approximately $3.71 – $9.12 per square foot, or $371 – $912 per square (a roofing square covers 100 sq. feet).

Pro Tip:  Don’t just focus on the lowest price. Ask about warranties, the quality of the shingles used, and the contractor’s experience to make sure you’re getting good value for your money.

Asphalt shingles might be the perfect fit for your Staten Island home, or they might just be a stepping stone to exploring other options. Either way, you now have the knowledge to make a decision that feels right. Remember, balancing budget, looks, and durability is key!

Get in touch with the team at ProLine Roofing! We can help you assess your roofing needs, discuss the pros and cons of different materials, and give you a clear picture of the costs involved.


Persistent Leaks Ruining Your Home? We've Got You Covered.

Fast, Reliable Repairs and Replacements. Get Your Free Quote Today.