Metal against shingles
The honest comparison is cost against time. Architectural shingles cost less now and typically last 20 to 30 years. A good metal roof costs more now and typically lasts 40 years or more, sheds snow and water quickly, and handles wind well. If you will be in the house long enough to replace a shingle roof twice, metal can come out ahead; if you plan to sell in a few years, shingles usually make more sense.
We put both prices in writing for your roof, so the decision rests on real numbers rather than a sales pitch.
Types of metal roofing
- Standing seam: long panels with raised, interlocking seams and concealed fasteners. Clean lines, fewer places for water to get in, and the longest-lasting option.
- Exposed-fastener panels: screwed through the face of the panel. Cheaper, but the screw washers need checking over the years.
- Metal shingles: pressed to look like shingles, slate or shakes, for homeowners who want metal’s lifespan with a traditional look.
What a metal roof needs underneath
Like any roof, metal depends on a sound deck, the right underlayment and proper flashing at every chimney, wall and vent. Metal moves as it heats and cools, so the system has to allow for that movement. The estimate names the panel system and how it will be fastened and flashed.
Commercial buildings
For stores, warehouses and other commercial buildings with metal roofs, see commercial roofing. For the standard shingle option, see asphalt shingle roofs.